Facebook as Fight Club — self expression and social media

“What is hell? Hell is oneself.
Hell is alone, the other figures in it merely projections.
There is nothing to escape from and nothing to escape to.
One is always alone.”
— T. S. Eliot, The Cocktail Party



Over the last few years there has been much talk around the psychological implications of social media.

Some say we are losing our ability to socialize face-to-face, that our online personas are fabrications — that being, is less important than being “seen”.

In her article Social Media has Distorted our True Sense of Self, Priya Virmani says technology has taken the spontaneity out of life and is now breeding a culture of manipulation. She says the online world is a carefully constructed domain made for public consumption —including our online representations and the relationships forged as a result.

Huffington Post writer R. Kay Green gives this anxiety a slightly more positive angle, in her article The Social Media Effect: Are you Really Who You Portray Online? Green says creating an ideal version of yourself online can actually inspire you to be better in reality due to the positive reinforcement from followers.

However, the sense of “ideal self” verses “real self” was around long before Instagram.

In the 50s, psychologist Carl Rogers said the concept of “self” has three components: self-image, the view you have of yourself; self-esteem, how much value you place on yourself; and the ideal self, what you wish you were really like.

Similarly Sigmund Freud believed the unconscious part of our brain contains our truest feelings and desires and could only be accessed during sleep when the expectations and demands of the Ego and Superego (society and environment) were not at play.

fight-club-3Social media sites such as Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, and Pinterest provide an outlet for both Rogers’ concept of the ideal self and Freud’s notion of the subconscious because they allow for more honest expression and stream of consciousness application.

We can feel alone out at the bar, we can feel alone at parties, we can feel alone at work — but we never feel alone on the Internet.

A friend you spend time with in person, may feel the person you are on Tumblr is not honest, but how often do we tell people what is really on our mind, how we actually feel or what our deepest desires are? Every conversation is a careful dance whether we realize it or not.

Which brings me to Fight Club.

In his 1996 novel, Chuck Palahniuk explores many of the anxieties plaguing American society. Although it was written before social media — or even mainstream use of the Internet, Palahniuk’s description of unconscious repression is still relevant today. The character of Tyler Durden — although sinister — represents the narrator’s alter ego or his “ideal self”. In the desire for freedom from societies expectations and his boring life, the narrator uses Durden and fight club to escape and be himself for the first time without inhibition.

What do you think? Is Facebook is Fight Club? Is social media the only place we can be truly honest — or is it breeding a culture of manipulation and dishonesty?

Facebook post: Is Facebook our Fight Club? Finding freedom in social media.
Twitter post: Tyler Durden used his fists — we tweet to escape. #fightclubisfreedom


2 thoughts on “Facebook as Fight Club — self expression and social media

  1. I like your line “but how often do we tell people what is really on our mind, how we actually feel or what our deepest desires are?” I do believe social media gives us the opportunity to share our authentic selves and to open up more. I remember when I was in university, signing up for Facebook and Twitter, and being able to share my interest in pop culture. My new university friends were able to see my interest – probably sooner than they would have just by talking to me – and I do believe it helped me with forming friendships faster. I think social media is an especially useful tool for introverts, who may struggle more to open up in person. But do you think social media is helpful in its ability to do this, or do you think it’s enabling people to stay in their comfort zone and avoid putting themselves out there?

  2. There is a really interesting Ted Talk about the hidden influence of social networks that you should check out. We like to think that the influence of social media on how we perceive or present ourselves to others is a relatively new phenomenon, but it really is just the expansion of our ability to express what we have always been expressing in way that connects us with an even greater audience than ever before.

    Think of the way we present ourselves differently to bosses, our family, people we have just met. We’ve always had a culture of “manipulation” if you want to call it that or are we just presenting certain character traits of ourselves to meet the needs of the audience or social situation we are in.

    Social networks have been a component of our human experience and in the video above, even have a genetic aspect in terms of how we participate in them. If anything, social media has created a comfortable space for introverts who may struggle to open up in larger social situations as Leigh suggested in the comment above. It also has enabled extroverts to display themselves in way that exposes them to an even greater audience of other extorverts and sometimes to the dismay of introverts. 😀

    Nicholas Christakis says in his Ted talk that “the benefits of a connected life, outweigh the costs.” Whether we are representing ourselves in a way that is truly authentic to the person we really are or creating a personna for ourselves based on how we wish we were, “the spred of good and nourishable things is required to sustain a network” according to Nicholas. So really, in the scheme of things, how important is it that we mean what we say all the time, so long as we are aspiring to it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.